Choosing to install a pool is a big decision—one that not only affects your lifestyle but also your property’s value and ongoing maintenance responsibilities. Among the first questions homeowners face is the classic debate: concrete vs fibreglass pools. Both options offer unique benefits and come with distinct challenges. But which one truly deserves a spot in your backyard?

This article dives deep into every angle—installation, cost, customization, longevity, maintenance, and aesthetics—so you can make an informed, confident choice. Let’s settle this pool showdown once and for all.

---

1. Installation Time & Process

Concrete Pools: Built to Order

Concrete pools are custom-built from scratch on your property. This means you can create virtually any shape, size, or depth your heart desires. However, this freedom comes at a price: time.

• Installation Time: Typically takes 8–12 weeks, depending on weather, permits, and complexity.

• Process: Excavation → steel framing → plumbing → concrete shell (gunite or shotcrete) → curing → tiling/plaster → filling.

Pros:
✅ Highly customizable
✅ Good for unique or large designs

Cons:
❌ Long installation timeline
❌ Subject to weather delays

Fibreglass Pools: Pre-Made Perfection

Fibreglass pools are factory-molded shells delivered in one piece and placed into an excavated hole. This method is much quicker and more predictable.

• Installation Time: Usually completed in 7–14 days.

• Process: Excavation → plumbing → delivery and placement → backfilling → decking.

Pros:
✅ Fast and efficient installation
✅ Less room for on-site errors

Cons:
❌ Limited shapes and sizes
❌ Transportation restrictions

Verdict: If speed is your top priority, fibreglass wins this round.

---

2. Cost Comparison: Upfront and Long-Term

When comparing concrete vs fibreglass pools, it’s crucial to weigh both the upfront investment and long-term expenses.

Initial Costs

• Concrete Pools: Typically $50,000–$100,000+, depending on size, complexity, and finishes.

• Fibreglass Pools: Generally $35,000–$70,000, including shell, delivery, and basic installation.

Ongoing Maintenance Costs

• Concrete Pools: Rough surface encourages algae growth, requiring more chemicals and frequent brushing.

• Fibreglass Pools: Smooth, non-porous surface resists algae and needs fewer chemicals.

Resurfacing

• Concrete pools need resurfacing every 10–15 years, costing $10,000–$20,000+.

• Fibreglass pools rarely require resurfacing unless damaged, offering long-term savings.

Verdict: Fibreglass pools typically offer better long-term value with lower maintenance and resurfacing costs.

---

3. Customization & Aesthetics

Your pool should reflect your lifestyle and taste. Here’s how the two options compare when it comes to design flexibility.

Concrete Pools: Limitless Creativity

• You can design freeform shapes, vanishing edges, tanning ledges, and more.

• Ideal for custom landscaping or unique backyard layouts.

Fibreglass Pools: Sleek but Standard

• Offered in a set range of shapes and sizes.

• Modern manufacturers provide stylish designs, but customization is still limited.

Verdict: Concrete pools dominate when it comes to creative freedom and design versatility.

---

4. Durability and Longevity

Durability is key to ensuring your pool investment stands the test of time.

Concrete Pools

• Built strong and can last 50+ years with proper care.

• Susceptible to surface cracks, algae, and chemical erosion over time.

Fibreglass Pools

• Can last 25–30+ years, with fewer structural issues.

• Surface is resistant to stains, algae, and cracking.

Verdict: Concrete pools are stronger structurally and last longer with maintenance, but fibreglass offers a low-maintenance, long-lasting shell with fewer problems.

---

5. Maintenance Requirements

Let’s face it—no one wants to spend more time cleaning than swimming.

Concrete Pools

• Porous surface = more brushing and chemicals.

• Needs acid washing every few years.

• Higher electricity costs due to stronger pumps for circulation.

Fibreglass Pools

• Smooth, algae-resistant surface.

• Less chemical use, minimal brushing.

• More energy-efficient with modern pump compatibility.

Verdict: Fibreglass pools win the low-maintenance crown hands down.

---

6. Feel Underfoot and Comfort

While this may seem like a minor point, the tactile experience of walking and swimming in the pool matters.

• Concrete: Can be rough and abrasive. Not ideal for kids who love to play for hours.

• Fibreglass: Smooth and gentle on feet, making it more comfortable for long swims.

Verdict: Fibreglass offers a better user experience for sensitive feet.

---

7. Repairs and Damage

No pool is invincible, but how repairs are handled differs between the two.

• Concrete Pools: Cracks can occur over time and often require professional repairs.

• Fibreglass Pools: Though less likely to crack, fixing gelcoat damage can be complex and must match factory finish.

Verdict: Both types can be repaired, but concrete issues are more common and may be costlier.

---

8. Resale Value and Buyer Appeal

Looking ahead, how does your choice affect property value?

• Concrete Pools: May appeal to luxury buyers due to customization, but potential buyers may factor in higher maintenance.

• Fibreglass Pools: Appeal to families and buyers who want low-maintenance outdoor living.

Verdict: It depends on your market. In general, fibreglass pools are a strong selling point for buyers looking for easy upkeep.

---

9. Environmental Impact

Eco-conscious homeowners should also consider which option is more sustainable.

• Concrete Pools: Require more water, chemicals, and energy over their lifetime.

• Fibreglass Pools: More energy-efficient and need fewer chemicals.

Verdict: Fibreglass is typically the greener choice.

---

The Final Verdict: Concrete vs Fibreglass Pools

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer in the concrete vs fibreglass pools debate. It all comes down to your priorities:

Choose Concrete if:

• You want a custom-designed pool with premium finishes.

• Budget and maintenance are less of a concern.

• You have a complex backyard layout or specific design vision.

Choose Fibreglass if:

• You prefer quick installation and lower maintenance.

• You’re budget-conscious over the long term.

• You want a smooth, comfortable, energy-efficient pool.

---

Final Thoughts

When weighing concrete vs fibreglass pools, it’s about aligning your pool choice with your lifestyle, budget, and long-term goals. Whether you go custom with concrete or streamlined with fibreglass, both can bring years of fun, relaxation, and added value to your home.

Before making your decision, consult with local pool builders, consider your backyard’s limitations, and think ahead—not just to the first summer, but to the next 20 years of ownership.