Exceptions: When Employers Are Liable for Independent Contractors
1. Inherently Dangerous Activities
Some operations have risks that remain, even with safety measures in place. Employers may be held strictly liable if they contract these activities.
Common Inherently Dangerous Activities:
-
- Demolition and blasting operations
- High-rise construction
- Handling of toxic chemicals
- Electrical line installation
- Hazardous material transportation
Legal Rationale:
-
- Public safety comes first. It cannot be delegated in contracts.
- Shared Responsibility: If you benefit from risky work, you also share the risk.
Even if you hire skilled contractors, you might still face liability. This is because the risk comes from the activity itself, not how it’s done.
2. Negligent Hiring, Supervision, or Retention
Employers need to pick, manage, and hold onto contractors wisely. If they’re not, they could be held responsible for any harm that happens.
Elements of Negligent Hiring:
-
- Employer knew or should have known of contractor’s incompetence.
- Contractor’s incompetence was a proximate cause of injury.
- The injury was foreseeable.
3. Retention of Control
If employers take charge of crucial work elements, they can change a contractor’s role to resemble that of an employee.
Indicators of Retained Control:
-
- Dictating work methods rather than just results.
- Involvement in daily operations.
- Supervisory presence on-site.
- Issuance of detailed procedural instructions.
4. Statutory and Regulatory Duties
Some laws say employers must follow certain rules, even if they hire contractors.
Examples:
-
- Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) regulations.
- Environmental compliance laws.
- Building code enforcement.
If these duties are broken, the employer might still be responsible. This could happen even if the worker is considered an independent contractor.
Legal Doctrines Intersecting with Contractor Liability
Non-Delegable Duty Doctrine
Employers can’t pass on some legal duties, even if independent contractors do the work.
Joint Enterprise Theory
If different entities team up on a project, they might all be responsible if their actions cause harm.
Apparent Authority
If a contractor acts like an employee, the employer could be held responsible. This can happen if the employer allows it.
Jurisdictional Variations
Liability rules can vary by state and jurisdiction. For instance:
-
- California emphasizes statutory duties.
- New York has strict public safety standards.
- Texas follows common law, but it has exceptions for dangerous situations.
Employers need to look at local laws and past cases to understand their risks better.
Implications for Insurance and Risk Management
Employers should talk to insurance experts to create complete coverage. This includes:
-
- General liability policies
- Contractor-specific endorsements
- Umbrella liability policies
- Professional liability coverage
Insurance planning can lower some financial risks. However, it does not eliminate legal responsibility.
